Skip to content

Looking for a Smith.ai alternative? How to compare AI receptionists

A fair way to compare receptionist services: human versus AI, the three pricing models, follow-up, data location and contract terms.

By the 1bb.ai team · · 4 min read

If you are searching for an alternative to Smith.ai, or to any receptionist service, you already know the problem you are solving: calls are going unanswered and each one is a customer. What you need now is a way to compare options that doesn't depend on whose marketing page is most persuasive.

This guide is that framework. It deliberately doesn't quote other companies' prices or features, because those change and a blog post is the wrong place to learn them. For a side-by-side with the figures taken from Smith.ai's own pricing page and the date we read it, see 1bb.ai vs Smith.ai.

First decision: a person, an AI, or both

Receptionist services come in three forms, and the right one depends on your calls more than on the technology.

  • Human receptionists. A trained person answers in your business name. Best when calls are long, emotional or unpredictable, and when a caller would be put off by anything automated. The trade-off is cost per call and, at busy times, capacity.
  • AI receptionists. Software answers in seconds, at any hour, and can take several calls at once. Best for calls that follow a pattern: booking, quotes, questions about hours and services, taking a message. The trade-off is that an AI has to be told what it knows, and it should hand off or take a message when a call goes outside that.
  • A mix. AI answers first and passes some calls to a person, either the vendor's staff or your own team.

A useful exercise: write down your last twenty calls and mark each one as routine or not. If most are routine, an AI receptionist with a clean handoff to your own team will cover them. If most are not, pay for people.

The three pricing models

Almost every service bills in one of three ways. None is wrong, but they reward different call patterns.

How receptionist services bill, and what to watch for with each model
ModelHow you are billedWhat to watchSuits
Per callA set number of calls a month, then a fee for each extra call.Whether short calls, wrong numbers and spam count as calls.Low volume, long calls.
Per minuteA bundle of minutes, then a rate for each extra minute.The rate past the bundle, and how minutes are rounded.Short, predictable calls.
Flat with fair useOne monthly price with an allowance set well above normal use.What the allowance is and what happens beyond it.Volume that swings by season.

The only way to compare them is with your own numbers. Take a normal month and a busy month. For each service, work out the bill in both. The service that looks cheapest in the normal month is often not the cheapest in the busy one, and the busy month is when you most need your calls answered.

What happens after the call

Answering is half the job. Compare what each service does once the caller hangs up. Do you get a summary immediately, or a daily digest? Is each call labelled with what happened, so you can see booked jobs apart from callbacks? If someone hangs up before speaking to anyone, does a text go out to them? Can the service book straight into your calendar, or does it only take a message?

These differences rarely show up in a price table, and they decide how many answered calls turn into work.

Where your data lives

Call recordings and transcripts contain your customers' names, numbers and problems. Ask every vendor where that is stored, who can access it, how long it is kept, and whether your data is separated from other customers'. If you are a Canadian business, or you serve regulated clients, the country matters. So does whether callers are told the call is recorded.

Contract terms worth reading

  • Is it month to month, or is there a minimum term?
  • Are there setup fees, and are they optional?
  • If you are given a phone number, what happens to it when you leave?
  • Can you change plans mid-month, in both directions?
  • Is there a guarantee, and what exactly triggers it?

A twenty-minute test

Shortlist two services and phone each one as three different customers: a routine booking, a question it can't possibly know the answer to, and something urgent. Note how fast it answered, whether it made anything up, and what you received afterwards. Twenty minutes of this beats any feature list.

Where 1bb.ai fits, and where it doesn't

1bb.ai is an AI receptionist, not a human answering service. It bills a flat monthly price with a fair-use allowance of 300, 1,000 or 2,500 minutes depending on the plan. Past that it keeps answering, and extra minutes are $0.25 each. Calls under ten seconds and spam don't count. It summarises and labels every call, texts back callers who hang up early, books into Google Calendar, and on the Growth and Scale plans can put a caller through to your own team. Plans are month to month. Pricing is here.

It is not the right choice for everyone. If your callers need a trained person on every call, choose a service with human receptionists. It launched in Canada first, with Canadian numbers and prices in Canadian dollars. And connections to field-service and practice-management software are still rolling out, so if that link is essential on day one, check before you commit.

Before comparing prices at all, it helps to know what an unanswered call costs you. This guide walks through the sum, and the calculator does it for you.

The next call is a job. Answer it.

Set up in five minutes. Flat monthly price. If it doesn't recover a lead in your first 30 days, that month is free.